Tres bien! Sehr gut!

Es war eine schoene Zeit bei ihr, Deutsch zu ueben!! Alles ist klar und organiziert.:)

Dankeschön! You're so patient.

必須遺憾的說 這次體驗課不是一個好的體驗, 首先是音質問題, 幾乎老師說的每一句都有破音的聲音,與老師反映後, 得到的回應是, 他教了很多學生, 沒有人和他反映這個問題, 最後也沒有打算解決這個問題, 更反駁他也有聽到我的背景有雜音啊, 不懂這是想表達什麼意思. 再來, 我第一堂體驗課通常會想了解未來的上課模式, 因為我的法文程度還不夠溝通, 因此以英文詢問, 與老師表示希望加強發音和閱讀, 在溝通還沒有共識時, 老師就用不太好的口氣說: 你不是想說法文, 我只聽到你一直說英文. 我多次表達想理解上課模式時, 老師自顧自在筆記寫下I want to speak French = Je veux parler français 並開始講解這句話的文法, 完全無法溝通. 只好繼續順著老師讀教材上的自我介紹例句. 且老師對例句的發音十分模糊, 又加上音質經常破音, 課程品質非常差. 此外, 上課過程我多次和老師表達, 我可以理解教材上的例句意思, 只是無法準確地唸出來, 這部分老師依然無法溝通, 例句含糊地唸過一次後, 就不斷用英文和中文詢問我懂不懂意思, 儘管我多次表達可以理解意思, 只是唸不出來, 情況依舊沒有任何改善. 最後, 在課程架構上, 即使我多次詢問上課模式, 得到的回答十分模糊, 一方面說我想做什麼都可以, 或秀出一些教材, 但只是把教材展示出來, 對於具體怎麼上課的細節還是完全沒有共識, 對於我一整堂課不斷表達想改善閱讀與發音的需求, 也沒有得到任何具體的結果. 只能說, 不管是上課體驗或和老師的溝通都不好. 但看老師其他評價的反應不錯, 也許這次體驗只是個例, 給予3顆星. It is regrettable to say that this trial lesson was not a good experience. Firstly, there was an issue with the sound quality; almost every sentence the teacher spoke had a cracking sound. After reflecting this to the teacher, the response was that he has taught many students and no one else has reported this problem. In the end, there was no intention to solve this issue, and instead, he countered by saying that he also heard noise from my background. I don't understand what he meant by that. Furthermore, in my first trial lesson, I usually want to understand the future class format. Since my French level is not good enough for communication, I asked in English. I expressed to the teacher that I wanted to improve my pronunciation and reading. Before we reached a consensus, the teacher said in an unpleasant tone, "You don't want to speak French, I only hear you speaking English." When I repeatedly tried to understand the class format, the teacher just wrote in his notes "I want to speak French = Je veux parler français" and started explaining the grammar of this sentence, making communication impossible. I had no choice but to follow the teacher and read the self-introduction examples in the textbook. The teacher's pronunciation of the examples was very unclear, and with the sound quality often breaking up, the lesson quality was very poor. Additionally, during the lesson, I repeatedly told the teacher that I could understand the meaning of the example sentences in the textbook, but I couldn't pronounce them accurately. The teacher still could not communicate this. After vaguely pronouncing the examples once, he kept asking me in English and Chinese if I understood the meaning, even though I had repeatedly said I understood the meaning but couldn't pronounce it. The situation did not improve at all. Finally, regarding the class structure, even though I repeatedly asked about the class format, the answers were very vague. On one hand, he said I could do whatever I wanted, or showed some materials, but just displaying the materials without any concrete details on how the class would be conducted left us with no consensus at all. Despite expressing my desire to improve my reading and pronunciation throughout the entire lesson, there were no specific results. Overall, the experience with the lesson and communication with the teacher was poor. However, considering the teacher's other reviews are quite positive, perhaps this experience was just an exception. I will give 3 stars.

關於整體課程安排，老師非常有經驗，可以很快速掌握學生程度並給予適當教材與指導，很能對症下藥。課堂中的口說練習，老師會即刻性的給予指教，對口語表達力很有幫助。對於中階以上學習者，老師會非常清楚解說字彙使用的差異，能幫助學生做出更貼近母語使用者的表達。每堂課後幾乎都會有小作業，老師會帶著學生一起修改，學生可以從得到的反饋中進步更快。上課風格，風趣、有效率。每次都很期待從課堂中學到更多!

我花了快要一年半的時間完成了A1的法語課程，這段學習的旅程讓我感到非常滿足和開心：從最初對法語毫無概念，到現在可以聽懂老師的問題並做出回應，進步的過程讓我深感驚喜和自豪。 Julie老師教學充滿無限耐心和鼓勵，總是不厭其煩地解答我的問題，並提供清晰明瞭的說明。這種溫暖和寬容的教學氛圍讓我可以無壓力、自在地學習。Julie老師每次的鼓勵和肯定都讓我對學習法語充滿信心，並且激勵我想要繼續努力！ 非常感謝Julie用心教導和鼓勵，簡直就是我法語學習之路的人生明燈！！！謝謝ㄧJulie!!!

这位老师说要帮助我过TCF Canada, 然后自称很了解这个考试，结果被我看到在课上： 当着我的面和我一起查看这个考试官网的考试要求，因为他其实对口语和写作的要求都不是很清楚。 教写作的时候，教的是错误的方向，当我说不知道怎么想idea的时候，他并灭有引导我去想，而是换了一个内容做，想要引开话题。当我问他为什么不练写作的时候，他就说我质疑他，还对我发火，这点我非常不满意，我对这个老师说，如果你不是很清楚这个考试的方向和要求的话，我们可以来练习别的内容，但是他就觉得我在侮辱他的能力，还和我说，这些考试，我只需要花几分钟看看了解一下就可以了。后来我还问了我的朋友，我发现这个老师教的写作的内容是错误的，误导人的。不光如此，还要跟我发火，我来上课又不是来受气的。总之，我觉得很不讲道理，这是非常自我的老师，希望大家慎重报课！ 在练习口语的时候，他还一直强调口语Tache2 要说服考官，但是这个明明就是TEF Canada的考试内容，所以我认为他是对我要考的试不清楚的，但是他本人不服气，认为我质疑他的能力。 En plus, 好两次都用油管的视频来混课，而且这就算了，给我找的油管的视频超出我等级很多范围，一般都是找学生能看懂百分之七八十的内容，但是这个老师找的内容太难，完全不符合我的情况。

我目前上了Emiel老師的5堂課，Emiel 老師很親切、有耐心。 前面老師幫我準備了面試練習，老師準備了很多題目，明知是練習還是很有臨場感，然後我也順利通過面試。（當然我自己也有認真準備，不是只靠老師） 上課時，在我想表達但不太通順時，Emiel會留給我足夠的時間，並在我講完一段後，告訴我更通順、常用的說法。可以切換英文跟法文，對我而言是一大幫助，讓我能更快的理解老師的說明。老師也很細心，會在說明時觀察我的表情，如果看起來有點困惑，就會立刻問我是否理解？並試著舉例說明。 我是已經學過法文的人，目前上課是為了想更熟悉法文、熟練英文，為到歐洲的生活做準備。所以對於老師適合教初學者還是進階，我沒有概念，但如果你需要一位願意循循善誘、耐心、用心準備的老師，推薦來上Emiel老師的課～！